New Orleans Floods vs Mumbai Floods...
I read an article in TOI regarding the floods that wrecked Mumbai and New Orleans and then thought forget it. The article was something like Vada Pav in Mumbai and Shooting/Looting in New Orleans. I believe people came all out at the time of floods in Mumbai and helped each other with Vada and Pav, where as in New Orleans it was shooting and looting! However, I just read a forward from my friend and could not stop sharing it across...Check this out...(not sure what was the source)
Inches of rain in new orleans due to hurricane katrina... 18
Inches of rain in mumbai (July 27th).... 37.1
Population of new orleans... 484,674
Population of mumbai.... 12,622,500
Deaths in new orleans within 48 hours of katrina...100
Deaths in mumbai within 48hours of rain.. 37.
Number of people to be evacuated in new orleans...entire city..wohh
Number of people evacuated in mumbai...10,000
Cases of shooting and violence in neworleans...Countless
Cases of shooting and violence in mumbai.. NONE
Time taken for US army to reach new orleans... 48hours
Time taken for Indian army and navy to reachmumbai...12hours
Status 96 hours later...new Orleans is still waiting for relief, army and electricty
status 96 hours later..mumbai is back on its feet andis business is as usual
USA...world's most developed nation
India...third world country
..oopss...did i get the last fact wrong???
Inches of rain in new orleans due to hurricane katrina... 18
Inches of rain in mumbai (July 27th).... 37.1
Population of new orleans... 484,674
Population of mumbai.... 12,622,500
Deaths in new orleans within 48 hours of katrina...100
Deaths in mumbai within 48hours of rain.. 37.
Number of people to be evacuated in new orleans...entire city..wohh
Number of people evacuated in mumbai...10,000
Cases of shooting and violence in neworleans...Countless
Cases of shooting and violence in mumbai.. NONE
Time taken for US army to reach new orleans... 48hours
Time taken for Indian army and navy to reachmumbai...12hours
Status 96 hours later...new Orleans is still waiting for relief, army and electricty
status 96 hours later..mumbai is back on its feet andis business is as usual
USA...world's most developed nation
India...third world country
..oopss...did i get the last fact wrong???
6 Comments:
At September 09, 2005 9:48 AM,
vimal said…
Very wrong comparison.
Very wrong.
What happened in Mumbai was torrential rain over 2-3 days.
Not a dump like Katrina.
Mumbai did not have a overflowing lake and a river.
Most important of all , very imporant.
Mumbai is not like a bowl.
New Orleans was liek a bowl, with water on all 3 sides.
A water in plate(mumbai) , water in bowl (new orleans) ... which is east to remove ?
Then again, Mumbai itself has a Navy, so navy don't have to go to mumbai, they were already there :)
Considering navy was already there, 12 hours is lot of time.
And one more, In US, every state is run liek a country. They have local & state govt capable of doing almost everything. The local & state's system totally collapsed on Katrina.
Whereas in India, its always central(federal) government.
At September 09, 2005 12:08 PM,
VJ said…
C'mon Vimal - don't tell me this is a completely wrong comparison. I agree with you about Mumbai not being like a bowl and yes it was torrential rain - but the city was flooded without doubt. You saw the pictures. And again considering the size of the plate - it is not like tilting it and getting the water out.
Watching the news every day, even the news channels are suprised that this is happening in US. They simply can't take the fact that it took 48 hours to respond - even if there is no army base in New Orleans - it does not take more than 2 hours from Texas! Even for the relief to get to New Orleans - it took a couple of days. No one can deny that. I was watching the NBC yday and the correspondent was telling that these guys were starting to give ideas to the Security forces about air lifting and stuff.
Shooting and Looting...thats ridiculous...
At September 09, 2005 1:32 PM,
vimal said…
And one more, In US, every state is run liek a country. They have local & state govt capable of doing almost everything. The local & state's system totally collapsed on Katrina.
Thats the key.
The local and state departments completely failed. They are the first line of defense. The FEMA comes only after that.
Also FEMA is not an independent entity who works alone. They usually plug-in to the existing local and state infrastructure and work with them. Since in this case the local and state infrastructure itself collapsed, FEMA had no way to plug-in anywhere. It was left all to FEMA, to act by itself.
Now is that a good design of FEMA ? thats a different question. If its not a good design, that shud have been addressd long time ago and not at the time of crisis.
In New Orleans, there were places where there were like 20 feet of water. Houses were completely submerged. Mumbai was no where near that.
When the warning was issued before hurriacen, the local and state authorities shuold have been the first one to have been better prepared to face the crisis. They both failed to do that.
So teh blame lies on all 3 entities.
Local, State and Federal.
So just blaming the Federal government alone is not at all fair in my opinion.
The problem with airlifting was..
when the rescuers tried to rescue some stranded people on roof tops in rescue helicopters, some maniac started shooting them. Duh !
So they had to halt many rescue missions.
Why would some one want to shoot a rescuer?
"They simply can't take the fact that it took 48 hours to respond - even if there is no army base in New Orleans - it does not take more than 2 hours from Texas! "
Yes, on a bright sunny day, where roads are neat, ya 2 hours.
What about when the roads are flooded, and you dont know where a road starts and where it ends.
Yes, maybe it takes two hours to drive from texas. But what is the point in driving without any supplies?
To collect the supplies, put them in a proper containers and to be travel ready....its gonna take some time.
Image
The above pic was taken i guess after 3-4 days. I can only imagine how it would have been 3-4 days before.
Mumbai was no where liek this. People could see the roads and walk in it.
Again, Iam not saying what is happenign there is acceptable. What Iam against is the total blame on federal government, when actually in reality, it had to be taken by all 3, local, state and federal authorities.
At September 09, 2005 3:25 PM,
VJ said…
Well, definitely in times such as this, roads can never be a route to reach a flooded city. It has to be choppers.
Am with you that the blame should be taken by all 3, local, state and federal authorities. Now they are re-assigning the FEMA Director and a new leader is gonna be sent to New Orleans.
Wonder why folks would be shooting at the folks who are trying to rescue them!
At September 09, 2005 3:55 PM,
vimal said…
http://www.cnn.com/2005/POLITICS/09/09/katrina.brown.reut/index.html
At least now this has to be fixed or else....it will be a case of 'never learned from the mistakes'.
At September 09, 2005 5:37 PM,
VJ said…
Absolutely!
Quote from Time - "Top FEMA officials are acting like Interns!"
Post a Comment
<< Home